科学技术哲学研究
科學技術哲學研究
과학기술철학연구
Science Technology and Dialectics
2013年
2期
53~57
,共null页
会话分析 优先组织 结构关系 面子理论
會話分析 優先組織 結構關繫 麵子理論
회화분석 우선조직 결구관계 면자이론
conversation analysis ; preference organization; structural relationship; face theory
现有的会话分析研究认为优先组织是言谈应对的结构特征,与交际者的个人欲望或心理倾向没有任何关系。我们认为这种抛弃语言使用者的心理因素,单纯关注语言结构的做法是不合适的。言谈应对是交际者在具体交际情境下的思想活动的体现,优先组织也不例外。非优先结构本质上是伤面子行为在言语层面的体现,交际者对于面子的考虑是他们进行话轮设计的决定因素之一。交际者对于伤面子行为的理解和文化认同是其构建具有非优先组织特征之话轮的前提和基础,即优先组织的礼貌解读。
現有的會話分析研究認為優先組織是言談應對的結構特徵,與交際者的箇人欲望或心理傾嚮沒有任何關繫。我們認為這種拋棄語言使用者的心理因素,單純關註語言結構的做法是不閤適的。言談應對是交際者在具體交際情境下的思想活動的體現,優先組織也不例外。非優先結構本質上是傷麵子行為在言語層麵的體現,交際者對于麵子的攷慮是他們進行話輪設計的決定因素之一。交際者對于傷麵子行為的理解和文化認同是其構建具有非優先組織特徵之話輪的前提和基礎,即優先組織的禮貌解讀。
현유적회화분석연구인위우선조직시언담응대적결구특정,여교제자적개인욕망혹심리경향몰유임하관계。아문인위저충포기어언사용자적심리인소,단순관주어언결구적주법시불합괄적。언담응대시교제자재구체교제정경하적사상활동적체현,우선조직야불예외。비우선결구본질상시상면자행위재언어층면적체현,교제자대우면자적고필시타문진행화륜설계적결정인소지일。교제자대우상면자행위적리해화문화인동시기구건구유비우선조직특정지화륜적전제화기출,즉우선조직적례모해독。
The existing researches in Conversation Analysis hold that preference organization is generalized and in- stitutionalized methods of speaking and in no way intends to refer to the private desires or psychological motivations of the speaker. We think that it is somewhat improper to focus purely on the structural level of communication while neglect the psychological element of the language users, because interaction is a process of communicators' choice making in specific context, and preference organization is no exception. We hold that the action lying behind the dispreferred organization is Face Threatening Act in nature and face is one of the essential elements that communi- cators have to consider in the process of turn design. Communicators' understanding of the nature of Face Threaten- ing Act is the basis of their constructing a turn with dispreferred property, and this is the politeness interpretation of the dispreferred organization.