河南科技大学学报:社会科学版
河南科技大學學報:社會科學版
하남과기대학학보:사회과학판
Journal of Henan University of Science & Technology:Social science
2013年
1期
89~94
,共null页
法律解释 司法克制 司法能动
法律解釋 司法剋製 司法能動
법률해석 사법극제 사법능동
interpretation of law; judicial restraint; judicial activism
法律是一种不断解释性概念,法律解释是法律适用的前提。作为法官释法的两种不同的司法《学,司法克制抑或司法能动的分歧集中于法官行使自由裁量权的限度。近年来,司法能动备受学者书崇,但也常被误读或曲解;实践中深受法官青睐,却多为之所滥用,甚至被异化为掠夺和扩张法律解释术的武器。当务之急,法官应当奉行司法克制,尊重并认真对待规则,依据法律文本的含义解释法律,审慎地建构裁判规范。
法律是一種不斷解釋性概唸,法律解釋是法律適用的前提。作為法官釋法的兩種不同的司法《學,司法剋製抑或司法能動的分歧集中于法官行使自由裁量權的限度。近年來,司法能動備受學者書崇,但也常被誤讀或麯解;實踐中深受法官青睞,卻多為之所濫用,甚至被異化為掠奪和擴張法律解釋術的武器。噹務之急,法官應噹奉行司法剋製,尊重併認真對待規則,依據法律文本的含義解釋法律,審慎地建構裁判規範。
법률시일충불단해석성개념,법률해석시법률괄용적전제。작위법관석법적량충불동적사법《학,사법극제억혹사법능동적분기집중우법관행사자유재량권적한도。근년래,사법능동비수학자서숭,단야상피오독혹곡해;실천중심수법관청래,각다위지소람용,심지피이화위략탈화확장법률해석술적무기。당무지급,법관응당봉행사법극제,존중병인진대대규칙,의거법률문본적함의해석법률,심신지건구재판규범。
Law is a kind of concept which needs to be interpreted ceaselessly, and application of law should be on the premise of interpretation of law. Judicial restraint or judicial activism impersonates derives from two distinct judicial philosophy of the interpreter of law, of which the focus of divergence of the two lies in the confine and limit of discretionary power which judge could perform. In recent years the scholars praised highly of judicial activism, but frequently misreading its meaning. In practice, judicial activism is in judge' s good graces and they have almost unlimited butout-of-order interpretation of law. It is pressing that the judge should pursue .judicial restraint and interpret the law strictly in conformity to the rule and then construct the adjudication rule in a conservative manner.