旅游学刊
旅遊學刊
여유학간
Tourism Tribune
2013年
4期
25~34
,共null页
条件价值法 WTP WTA 偏差 有效性 可靠性
條件價值法 WTP WTA 偏差 有效性 可靠性
조건개치법 WTP WTA 편차 유효성 가고성
contingent valuation method ; WTP ; WTA ; bias ; validity ; reliability
源于福利经济学和环境经济学的条件价值法是旅游资源经济价值评估的重要方法。文章对条件价值法评估旅游资源经济价值研究中存在的WTP—WTA不对称、各类偏差以及有效性和可靠性检验问题进行了详细的梳理和评析。在充分肯定条件价值法对于旅游资源经济价值评估适用性的基础上,提出旅游资源经济价值评估应进一步围绕发展中国家方法使用的独特性、旅游资源价值评估中利益相关群体的区别研究以及旅游资源价值评估的跨学科研究等方面展开,以期为国内相关研究提供参考和启示。
源于福利經濟學和環境經濟學的條件價值法是旅遊資源經濟價值評估的重要方法。文章對條件價值法評估旅遊資源經濟價值研究中存在的WTP—WTA不對稱、各類偏差以及有效性和可靠性檢驗問題進行瞭詳細的梳理和評析。在充分肯定條件價值法對于旅遊資源經濟價值評估適用性的基礎上,提齣旅遊資源經濟價值評估應進一步圍繞髮展中國傢方法使用的獨特性、旅遊資源價值評估中利益相關群體的區彆研究以及旅遊資源價值評估的跨學科研究等方麵展開,以期為國內相關研究提供參攷和啟示。
원우복리경제학화배경경제학적조건개치법시여유자원경제개치평고적중요방법。문장대조건개치법평고여유자원경제개치연구중존재적WTP—WTA불대칭、각류편차이급유효성화가고성검험문제진행료상세적소리화평석。재충분긍정조건개치법대우여유자원경제개치평고괄용성적기출상,제출여유자원경제개치평고응진일보위요발전중국가방법사용적독특성、여유자원개치평고중이익상관군체적구별연구이급여유자원개치평고적과학과연구등방면전개,이기위국내상관연구제공삼고화계시。
Typically environmental resource valuation studies concentrate on estimating total economic value, which includes not only the values of specific uses, but also the intangible non-use values not normally captured in private market transactions. Revealed preference methods are applicable only when data on market transactions or activities are available. Total economic value can be estimated using stated preference non-market valuation techniques. The contingent valuation method (CVM) , as a type of stated preference method, is a widely used non-market valuation method especially applicable in the areas of environmental cost-benefit analysis and environmental impact assessment. Its application in environmental economics includes estimation of non-use values, non-market use values or both of these measures of environmental resource values. Because of its capacity to capture both use and non-use values and provide valuation data when revealed preference information is lacking, CVM has become the most important non-market valuation technique and has been the most popular and widely used valuation technique over the past several decades.or scope effect considers whether a resource or good is presented as a separate unit or as a part of an aggregate of goods; 3 ) sequencing effect or question order bias considers if a willingness to pay (WTP) value assigned for a particular good differs depending on the order in which the good occurs in a sequence of options ; 4) hypothetical or strategic bias deals with when an unreal/hypothetical scenario setting is presented to respondents that may cause them to overstate or understate their true preferences; 5 ) payment vehicle bias considers situations when the payment method influences the assigned value, and so on. Also, problems caused by poor design and/or administration of many environmental valuation studies are widely recognized. Common problems include poorly defined or implausible goods and a low response rate. Currently, the CVM has become an integral part of environmental assessment and it is capable of eliciting the true economic values of environmental resources if properly conducted, such as its use in placing a value on tourism resources. The CVM shows promise and may be used to derive useful information. But this does not mean this method should be used indiscriminately. CVM studies should be conducted properly and extremely carefully. The major objective of this paper is to make a relatively detailed analysis of relevant literature from China and across the globe regarding any disparity between WTP and WTA, and the effects of various biases on the validity and the reliability of the results. Based on the belief that CVM shows promise as a method to valuate tourism resources, the authors consider the possible development and orientation of future studies including the possibility of using CVM in developing countries where valuation researchers typically survey the stakeholders. The need for interdisciplinary work is obvious in the hope of providing baseline data for land managers to assist them in making informed decisions based on relevant domestic studies.