华中科技大学学报:社会科学版
華中科技大學學報:社會科學版
화중과기대학학보:사회과학판
Journal of Huazhong University of Science and Technology(Social Science Edition)
2013年
3期
118~124
,共null页
城乡规划 法治 倾斜 平衡
城鄉規劃 法治 傾斜 平衡
성향규화 법치 경사 평형
urban and rural planning; role of law; tilting; balance
我国城乡规划法治的现在时态是农村向城市“倾斜”、社会向政府“倾斜”的形式主义法治。正是基于此,我国城乡规划法的现实运行面临的是利益的失衡与执行的困境。笔者主张城乡规划不仅要遵守法律的形式约束力,而且必须具有实质的正当性,其中的关键就是要消解城市与农村、政府与社会、法的应然性与实证性之间的紧张与冲突关系。中国城乡规划法治的未来期待是:保证城乡规划的区域利益中立,实现城乡规划的信息公开,落实城乡规划的权责对等的、“平衡”的实质主义法治。
我國城鄉規劃法治的現在時態是農村嚮城市“傾斜”、社會嚮政府“傾斜”的形式主義法治。正是基于此,我國城鄉規劃法的現實運行麵臨的是利益的失衡與執行的睏境。筆者主張城鄉規劃不僅要遵守法律的形式約束力,而且必鬚具有實質的正噹性,其中的關鍵就是要消解城市與農村、政府與社會、法的應然性與實證性之間的緊張與遲突關繫。中國城鄉規劃法治的未來期待是:保證城鄉規劃的區域利益中立,實現城鄉規劃的信息公開,落實城鄉規劃的權責對等的、“平衡”的實質主義法治。
아국성향규화법치적현재시태시농촌향성시“경사”、사회향정부“경사”적형식주의법치。정시기우차,아국성향규화법적현실운행면림적시이익적실형여집행적곤경。필자주장성향규화불부요준수법률적형식약속력,이차필수구유실질적정당성,기중적관건취시요소해성시여농촌、정부여사회、법적응연성여실증성지간적긴장여충돌관계。중국성향규화법치적미래기대시:보증성향규화적구역이익중립,실현성향규화적신식공개,락실성향규화적권책대등적、“평형”적실질주의법치。
The status quo of the rule of law in China's urban and rural planning is the formalism in the rule of law, with the rural area tilting to the urban area and the society tilting to the government. Based on this, there is imbalance of interests and the plight of implementation what the practical operation of China's ur- ban and rural planning law facing is the. This article argues that urban and rural planning should not only comply with the law in the form of binding but also must have substantial legitimacy, of which the key is to de- fuse the tension and conflict between the urban and rural areas, government and society, the law' s inevitabili- ty and positivitat. The future expectations of the rule of law in China's urban and rural planning is to ensure the neutralization of regional interests in the urban and rural planning, realize urban and rural planning infor- mation disclosure, and implement substantially the rule of law in the urban and rural planning with the balance and the equality of rights and responsibilities.