高等教育研究
高等教育研究
고등교육연구
Journal of Higher Education
2013年
3期
22~27
,共null页
大学自治 权利救济 宪法保障 司法平衡
大學自治 權利救濟 憲法保障 司法平衡
대학자치 권리구제 헌법보장 사법평형
university autonomy ; right relief ; constitution security ; judicial balance
台湾地区“大法官”在两个层面上对大学自治进行解释:在大学与国家公权力层面上,通过第380、450号解释,使大学自治获得宪法保障,不仅可以对抗行政机关的不法干涉,亦可以对抗立法者的不当干涉;在大学与其内部成员权利层面上,通过第382、684号解释,破除了传统的学校特别权力关系,学生获得了全面的诉讼请求权,使大学自治受到了制约。为平衡大学自治与权利救济,第462、563、626号解释构建了正当性审查的基本框架。其解释可为我们参考和借鉴。
檯灣地區“大法官”在兩箇層麵上對大學自治進行解釋:在大學與國傢公權力層麵上,通過第380、450號解釋,使大學自治穫得憲法保障,不僅可以對抗行政機關的不法榦涉,亦可以對抗立法者的不噹榦涉;在大學與其內部成員權利層麵上,通過第382、684號解釋,破除瞭傳統的學校特彆權力關繫,學生穫得瞭全麵的訴訟請求權,使大學自治受到瞭製約。為平衡大學自治與權利救濟,第462、563、626號解釋構建瞭正噹性審查的基本框架。其解釋可為我們參攷和藉鑒。
태만지구“대법관”재량개층면상대대학자치진행해석:재대학여국가공권력층면상,통과제380、450호해석,사대학자치획득헌법보장,불부가이대항행정궤관적불법간섭,역가이대항입법자적불당간섭;재대학여기내부성원권리층면상,통과제382、684호해석,파제료전통적학교특별권력관계,학생획득료전면적소송청구권,사대학자치수도료제약。위평형대학자치여권리구제,제462、563、626호해석구건료정당성심사적기본광가。기해석가위아문삼고화차감。
Taiwan "Judge" interpreted university autonomy from two aspects. From the aspect of the university and the national public power, university autonomy was safeguarded by the interpretation of the 380th and 450th, which could remove the intervenes of the ad ministration and the law enforcement agency; from the aspect of the university and the rights of internal members, university autonomy was restricted by the interpretation of the 382th and 684th, removing the traditional special power of the university and investing students with the full claim rights. To balance university autonomy and its internal members right re- lief, the interpretation of the 462nd, the 563rd and the 626th constructed the frame of legiti- macy review, which could offer beneficial references for us.