现代法学
現代法學
현대법학
Modern Law Science
2013年
3期
140~148
,共null页
内卷化 调解过密 人大代表 协助调解
內捲化 調解過密 人大代錶 協助調解
내권화 조해과밀 인대대표 협조조해
involution; mediation involution; NPC deputies; mediation assistance
在纠纷解决的资源视角下,法院调解资源的投放情况攸关调解的效能。由于缺乏传统"马锡五审判方式"所隐含的"熟人权威"资源背景,法官更多通过增加调解工作频度以弥补熟人资源的缺失,造成了诉讼调解的"内卷化"。地方实践中的人大代表协助诉讼调解,在人大代表介入调解的正当性基础上,通过常识性话语资源优势和社会资本优势,为法院调解提供了"意外"资源支持的机遇结构,在一定程度上改善了调解"内卷化"问题。
在糾紛解決的資源視角下,法院調解資源的投放情況攸關調解的效能。由于缺乏傳統"馬錫五審判方式"所隱含的"熟人權威"資源揹景,法官更多通過增加調解工作頻度以瀰補熟人資源的缺失,造成瞭訴訟調解的"內捲化"。地方實踐中的人大代錶協助訴訟調解,在人大代錶介入調解的正噹性基礎上,通過常識性話語資源優勢和社會資本優勢,為法院調解提供瞭"意外"資源支持的機遇結構,在一定程度上改善瞭調解"內捲化"問題。
재규분해결적자원시각하,법원조해자원적투방정황유관조해적효능。유우결핍전통"마석오심판방식"소은함적"숙인권위"자원배경,법관경다통과증가조해공작빈도이미보숙인자원적결실,조성료소송조해적"내권화"。지방실천중적인대대표협조소송조해,재인대대표개입조해적정당성기출상,통과상식성화어자원우세화사회자본우세,위법원조해제공료"의외"자원지지적궤우결구,재일정정도상개선료조해"내권화"문제。
From the perspective of dispute settlement,the allocation of judicial mediation resources concerns the effectiveness of successful mediation.Since the lack of the 'acquaintance authority' that could be found in the traditional Ma Xi-wu trial mode,judges have to employ more mediation practices and result in the involution of judicial mediation.In the local practices,the National People's Congress(NPC) deputies are active in assisting mediation.There is a legitimate role for NPC deputies who not only help to implant external dispute resolution resource by their knowledge,but also contribute to the dispute resolution.