中国行政管理
中國行政管理
중국행정관리
Chinese Public Administration
2013年
7期
89~92
,共null页
地方试验 法律控制 法国
地方試驗 法律控製 法國
지방시험 법률공제 법국
local experimentation, legal control, France
法国自20世纪60年代开始推行地方试验,同时由最高行政法院对其进行司法审查,以化解地方试验对国g':-}Vl统一的冲击,并保证试验措施充分发挥试验效用。尤其是2003年修宪进一步将地方试验宪法化,其实践折射出须以法律调控对地方试验“去弊扬利”,使地方试验制度具有明确的目标、限定的期限、科学的效果评估以及完善的程序设计。我国以往疏于对地方试验进行法律控制,全国人大常委会自2012年底开始尝试将地方试验法治化,就此可充分借鉴法国的法律制度。
法國自20世紀60年代開始推行地方試驗,同時由最高行政法院對其進行司法審查,以化解地方試驗對國g':-}Vl統一的遲擊,併保證試驗措施充分髮揮試驗效用。尤其是2003年脩憲進一步將地方試驗憲法化,其實踐摺射齣鬚以法律調控對地方試驗“去弊颺利”,使地方試驗製度具有明確的目標、限定的期限、科學的效果評估以及完善的程序設計。我國以往疏于對地方試驗進行法律控製,全國人大常委會自2012年底開始嘗試將地方試驗法治化,就此可充分藉鑒法國的法律製度。
법국자20세기60년대개시추행지방시험,동시유최고행정법원대기진행사법심사,이화해지방시험대국g':-}Vl통일적충격,병보증시험조시충분발휘시험효용。우기시2003년수헌진일보장지방시험헌법화,기실천절사출수이법률조공대지방시험“거폐양리”,사지방시험제도구유명학적목표、한정적기한、과학적효과평고이급완선적정서설계。아국이왕소우대지방시험진행법률공제,전국인대상위회자2012년저개시상시장지방시험법치화,취차가충분차감법국적법률제도。
Local experimentation in France was carried out since the 1960s, and since the same time the Conseil d~Etat began to exercise a judicial review on it, in order to reduce its conflict with the national legal system, and to guarantee the full use of experimental measures. The 2003 constitutional revision further confirmed the local experimentation system. The French practices illustrated that legal control system, the elements of which are definite purpose, limited dura- tion, scientific evaluation of effectiveness and perfect procedural design, is necessary to eliminate the shortcomings and make full use of local experimentation. Local experimentation in China was out of legal control, but the Standing Committee of NPC began to achieve the rule of law in local experimentation since the end of 2012, in which the French legal system could be inspiring.