CAJ | 학술논문

王晓军的《略论民国时期图书馆际互借》一文遗漏了严文郁、顾家杰等图书馆学人对民国馆际互借的论述以及其他若干史料，以致文中得出的部分论断值得推敲。该文对此进行了商榷和补遗，认为不应当过低评价民国馆际互借的水平，虽然当时未能形成全面的规范和全国性的规模，但认为“处于较低水平”不够恰当，至少用“具备了一定基础和规模”更反映客观史实。以史为鉴，从对影响民国时期馆际互借发展的若干因素分析中，得出几点对CALIS馆际互借服务的启示与建议。
왕효군적《약론민국시기도서관제호차》일문유루료엄문욱、고가걸등도서관학인대민국관제호차적논술이급기타약간사료，이치문중득출적부분론단치득추고。해문대차진행료상각화보유，인위불응당과저평개민국관제호차적수평，수연당시미능형성전면적규범화전국성적규모，단인위“처우교저수평”불구흡당，지소용“구비료일정기출화규모”경반영객관사실。이사위감，종대영향민국시기관제호차발전적약간인소분석중，득출궤점대CALIS관제호차복무적계시여건의。
The paper by Wang Xiaojun, A Study on Interlibrary Loan in the Period of Republic of China, leaves out the relative theses by Yen Wen Yu, Ku Chia Chie and some other scholars as well as several other historical materials, so that the conclusions drawn from the paper is yet partly to be discussed. With the discussion and supplement to the paper, this article argues that we should not evaluate the interli- brary loan in Republic of China era too low. It is not appropriate to evaluate the scale of interlibrary loan in Republic of China as ＂on low level＂, while it is more objective to redeem it as at least with certain foundation and absolute scale. Learning from history, some inspirations and suggestions on the interlibrary loan of CALIS can be drawn from the analysis on several influencing factor of the development of interlibrary loan in Republic of China era.