北京行政学院学报
北京行政學院學報
북경행정학원학보
Journal of Beijing Administrative College
2013年
5期
82~87
,共null页
拉德布鲁赫 法的真善美 法的理念 相对主义
拉德佈魯赫 法的真善美 法的理唸 相對主義
랍덕포로혁 법적진선미 법적이념 상대주의
Gustav Radbrueh; truth, goodness and beauty of law; the idea of law; relativism
法的真善美是相统一的。法的逻辑价值是真,法之真属于法律科学的对象;法的道德价值是善,法之善即正义:法的文化价值是美。拉德布鲁赫认为法的理念包括整体的正义、合目的、确定性三个要素,但其相互间又存在着对立。这个观点基本上是可取的。总体而言,虽然名之日“相对主义”,却充满着辩证的机理;借用“相对主义”无非是为了反对把问题绝对化,使法承栽正义,缔造与达至人类自由、平等与和谐。当然,此一别致的法哲学亦不免有值得商榷之处。
法的真善美是相統一的。法的邏輯價值是真,法之真屬于法律科學的對象;法的道德價值是善,法之善即正義:法的文化價值是美。拉德佈魯赫認為法的理唸包括整體的正義、閤目的、確定性三箇要素,但其相互間又存在著對立。這箇觀點基本上是可取的。總體而言,雖然名之日“相對主義”,卻充滿著辯證的機理;藉用“相對主義”無非是為瞭反對把問題絕對化,使法承栽正義,締造與達至人類自由、平等與和諧。噹然,此一彆緻的法哲學亦不免有值得商榷之處。
법적진선미시상통일적。법적라집개치시진,법지진속우법률과학적대상;법적도덕개치시선,법지선즉정의:법적문화개치시미。랍덕포로혁인위법적이념포괄정체적정의、합목적、학정성삼개요소,단기상호간우존재착대립。저개관점기본상시가취적。총체이언,수연명지일“상대주의”,각충만착변증적궤리;차용“상대주의”무비시위료반대파문제절대화,사법승재정의,체조여체지인류자유、평등여화해。당연,차일별치적법철학역불면유치득상각지처。
This paper discusses Radbruch' s law philosophy system of truth, goodness and beauty, his law concept and his relativism of law philosophy. The truth, goodness and beauty of law are perfectly integrated together: the logical value of law is the truth, which belongs to the object of jurisprudence the science of law; the ethical value of law is the goodness, that is, the justice; the cultural value of law is the beauty. Radbruch thought that the concept of law should be involved in justice, purposiveness and certainty, which oppose each other. This view is basically advisable. Generally speaking, Radbruch' s philosophy of law is dialectical and witty although it is named as the relativism. By using the term of the relativism, Radbruch supposed that law should promote justice and maintain freedom, equality and harmony of human being. Radbmch' s such a view is still open to discussion.