河北法学
河北法學
하북법학
Hebei Law Science
2013年
12期
168~175
,共null页
环境监管失职 国家赔偿 环境污染侵权 补充责任
環境鑑管失職 國傢賠償 環境汙染侵權 補充責任
배경감관실직 국가배상 배경오염침권 보충책임
dereliction of environmental regulatory responsibility; state compensation; environmental tort;complementary liability
环境监管失职致害应该承担国家赔偿责任,是因为国家负有环境污染侵害危险防止责任,普通民众也高度依赖于国家的环境污染侵害危险管理,因环境监管部门不履行或不适当履行监管职责,致使普通民众的生命、身体、健康等重大权益遭受损害,国家应当承担相应的赔偿责任。环境监管失职国家赔偿责任较之加害者的民事赔偿责任而言应属补充责任。对环境监管失职致害的损害救济,应允许受害人在国家与加害者之间进行选择。如果国家在履行赔偿责任之后,应承认其向加害者追偿的权利。
環境鑑管失職緻害應該承擔國傢賠償責任,是因為國傢負有環境汙染侵害危險防止責任,普通民衆也高度依賴于國傢的環境汙染侵害危險管理,因環境鑑管部門不履行或不適噹履行鑑管職責,緻使普通民衆的生命、身體、健康等重大權益遭受損害,國傢應噹承擔相應的賠償責任。環境鑑管失職國傢賠償責任較之加害者的民事賠償責任而言應屬補充責任。對環境鑑管失職緻害的損害救濟,應允許受害人在國傢與加害者之間進行選擇。如果國傢在履行賠償責任之後,應承認其嚮加害者追償的權利。
배경감관실직치해응해승담국가배상책임,시인위국가부유배경오염침해위험방지책임,보통민음야고도의뢰우국가적배경오염침해위험관리,인배경감관부문불리행혹불괄당리행감관직책,치사보통민음적생명、신체、건강등중대권익조수손해,국가응당승담상응적배상책임。배경감관실직국가배상책임교지가해자적민사배상책임이언응속보충책임。대배경감관실직치해적손해구제,응윤허수해인재국가여가해자지간진행선택。여과국가재리행배상책임지후,응승인기향가해자추상적권리。
The reason the State should burden compensation liability which results from dereliction of environmental regulatory responsibility is that the state has the duty to prevent environment hazard, and ordinary people are highly dependent on the state's environmental risk management. As environmental authority did not fulfill regulatory responsibilities seriously to prevent or deter life and health damage caused by environmental torts ,the state should bear corresponding compensation liability, and its nature is complementary compared to infringerS. In the process of damage relief,the victims should be allowed to choose a compensator from the state and the infringer, and the state has the right to claim to the inflicter after bearing compensation liability.