心理学报
心理學報
심이학보
Acta Psychologica Sinica
2014年
2期
143~155
,共null页
部分线索效应 情绪Stroop任务 提取抑制假说 策略破坏假说
部分線索效應 情緒Stroop任務 提取抑製假說 策略破壞假說
부분선색효응 정서Stroop임무 제취억제가설 책략파배가설
part-list cuing effect; emotional Stroop task; the retrieval inhibition hypothesis; the strategy disruption hypothesis
采用部分线索效应经典范式与情绪Stroop任务相结合的范式,采取更为敏感的指标,对部分线索效应的认知抑制进程进行了考察,同时为提取抑制假说提供证据。结果发现,部分线索呈现后进行情绪Stroop任务,部分线索组反应时显著短于自由回忆组,提取结束后进行情绪Stroop任务,部分线索组和自由回忆组反应时差异不显著,提取未完成时,部分线索组反应时显著短于自由回忆组。结果提示,在以情绪词为实验材料的部分线索效应中,抑制在部分线索呈现之后即发生,提取未完成时,抑制持续存在,研究结果支持提取抑制假说,同时也对提取抑制假说做了一定补充,即抑制的持续时间受随后是否有提取任务调节。
採用部分線索效應經典範式與情緒Stroop任務相結閤的範式,採取更為敏感的指標,對部分線索效應的認知抑製進程進行瞭攷察,同時為提取抑製假說提供證據。結果髮現,部分線索呈現後進行情緒Stroop任務,部分線索組反應時顯著短于自由迴憶組,提取結束後進行情緒Stroop任務,部分線索組和自由迴憶組反應時差異不顯著,提取未完成時,部分線索組反應時顯著短于自由迴憶組。結果提示,在以情緒詞為實驗材料的部分線索效應中,抑製在部分線索呈現之後即髮生,提取未完成時,抑製持續存在,研究結果支持提取抑製假說,同時也對提取抑製假說做瞭一定補充,即抑製的持續時間受隨後是否有提取任務調節。
채용부분선색효응경전범식여정서Stroop임무상결합적범식,채취경위민감적지표,대부분선색효응적인지억제진정진행료고찰,동시위제취억제가설제공증거。결과발현,부분선색정현후진행정서Stroop임무,부분선색조반응시현저단우자유회억조,제취결속후진행정서Stroop임무,부분선색조화자유회억조반응시차이불현저,제취미완성시,부분선색조반응시현저단우자유회억조。결과제시,재이정서사위실험재료적부분선색효응중,억제재부분선색정현지후즉발생,제취미완성시,억제지속존재,연구결과지지제취억제가설,동시야대제취억제가설주료일정보충,즉억제적지속시간수수후시부유제취임무조절。
When people are asked to recall items from a previously studied list and are given a subset of the items on that list as retrieval cues, they often do more poorly at recalling the remaining items on the list than do people asked to recall the items in the absence of such retrieval cues (Slamecka, 1968). Such part-list cuing effect has often been attributed to inhibitory executive-control processes that supposedly suppress the non-cue items' memory representation. Our aim in the present study was to further evaluate the inhibitory executive-control account of part-list cuing effect. Using a new paradigm which combines the classical part-list cuing paradigm with emotional Stroop task, adopting a more sensitive index, the present study retested the retrieval inhibition hypothesis of part-list cuing effect. Four experiments were included. In Experiments 1, we explored whether the inhibition occurs after the presence of part-list cues by inserting the emotional Stroop task between the presence of part-list cues and the retrieval phase, In Experiments 2 and 3, we explored whether the inhibition still persist after the retrieval phase by inserting the emotional Stroop task after the retrieval phase, On the basis of Experiment 2 and 3, in Experiment 4, an inadequate retrieval time was used to further investigate the inhibition process during the retrieval phase. The findings showed that: when the emotional Stroop task was performed after the presentation of the part-list cues, the reaction time of part-list cuing recall group was shorter than free recall group; while when the emotional Stroop task was performed after the retrieval phase, no difference between part-list cuing recall group and free recall group was observed; and when the retrieval was not fulfilled, the reaction time of part-list cuing recall group was shorter than free recall group. The present findings revealed that in the part-list cuing effect, inhibition occurred as soon as the part-list cues were provided, and before the full completion of the retrieval task, the inhibition process would persist. The results support the retrieval inhibition hypothesis of part-list cuing effect, and do some supplement to the retrieval inhibition hypothesis the duration of inhibition was mediated by the retrieval task.