出版科学
齣版科學
출판과학
2014年
2期
66~69
,共null页
期刊评价 读者缺位 文献计量学
期刊評價 讀者缺位 文獻計量學
기간평개 독자결위 문헌계량학
Evaluation of periodicals Absence of readers Bibliometrics
当前学术期刊评价中存在文献计量学越位、读者缺位、期刊评价功能异化的现象。在期刊评价中,论文引用率不能等同于读者评价,专家定性评价不能取代读者评价,Web即年下载率无法反馈读者评价。期刊改制是大势所趋,期刊评价中亟需重视读者评价。
噹前學術期刊評價中存在文獻計量學越位、讀者缺位、期刊評價功能異化的現象。在期刊評價中,論文引用率不能等同于讀者評價,專傢定性評價不能取代讀者評價,Web即年下載率無法反饋讀者評價。期刊改製是大勢所趨,期刊評價中亟需重視讀者評價。
당전학술기간평개중존재문헌계량학월위、독자결위、기간평개공능이화적현상。재기간평개중,논문인용솔불능등동우독자평개,전가정성평개불능취대독자평개,Web즉년하재솔무법반궤독자평개。기간개제시대세소추,기간평개중극수중시독자평개。
There existing the problems that are offside of bibliometrics, the absence of readers, and the dissimilation of periodical evaluation function at present. In the evaluation of periodicals, citation rate of papers is not equal to the evaluation of readers, the qualitative evaluation of experts can not replace the evaluation of the readers, and Web download rate can not feedback evaluation of readers. The evaluation of periodicals should pay more attention to the evaluation of readers in the periodical reform now.