科学技术哲学研究
科學技術哲學研究
과학기술철학연구
Science Technology and Dialectics
2014年
2期
25~29
,共null页
范弗拉森 结构实在论 结构经验主义
範弗拉森 結構實在論 結構經驗主義
범불랍삼 결구실재론 결구경험주의
Van Fraassen ; structural realism ; structural empiricism
在回应结构实在论对建构经验主义的挑战中,范弗拉森提出了结构经验主义的思想。按照范弗拉森,任一对象的内部元素都可以被赋予无数种合理的组合结构,结构实在论者要把那些本质的结构纳入研究视野,但却没有给出这种本质与非本质区分的合理根据。结构经验主义强调,具体语境决定了经验上恰当的组合结构。尽管结构经验主义理论还有许多困难,但还是丰富和完善了范弗拉森早期的建构经验主义。
在迴應結構實在論對建構經驗主義的挑戰中,範弗拉森提齣瞭結構經驗主義的思想。按照範弗拉森,任一對象的內部元素都可以被賦予無數種閤理的組閤結構,結構實在論者要把那些本質的結構納入研究視野,但卻沒有給齣這種本質與非本質區分的閤理根據。結構經驗主義彊調,具體語境決定瞭經驗上恰噹的組閤結構。儘管結構經驗主義理論還有許多睏難,但還是豐富和完善瞭範弗拉森早期的建構經驗主義。
재회응결구실재론대건구경험주의적도전중,범불랍삼제출료결구경험주의적사상。안조범불랍삼,임일대상적내부원소도가이피부여무수충합리적조합결구,결구실재론자요파나사본질적결구납입연구시야,단각몰유급출저충본질여비본질구분적합리근거。결구경험주의강조,구체어경결정료경험상흡당적조합결구。진관결구경험주의이론환유허다곤난,단환시봉부화완선료범불랍삼조기적건구경험주의。
Bas C. van Fraassen presented a structural empiricism recently to respond to the challenges of structural realism. According to van Fraassen, a domain has no inherent structure unless some properties and relations are im- posed on it, so every domain can have any assigned structure compatible with it. But the structural realist thinks that some of the structures are natural ones that have epistemological advantages. Van Fraassen criticized this view and proposed an structural empiricism claiming that we can determine the only appropriate structure if we make clear what the specific context we are in. There are some problems with this structural empiricism but it indeed enriches and completes the constructive empiricism van Fraassen had proposed.