湖南大学学报:社会科学版
湖南大學學報:社會科學版
호남대학학보:사회과학판
Journal of Hunan University(Social Sciences)
2014年
2期
150~154
,共null页
不判决停止侵权 合理性 合理补偿
不判決停止侵權 閤理性 閤理補償
불판결정지침권 합이성 합리보상
not support to cessation of infringement; rationality;reasonable compensation
专利侵权诉讼中,一般情况下,法院都会判决停止侵权。但由于专利产品的特殊性,有时停止侵权的判决会对公共利益和他人利益造成严重损害。在司法实践中,已经出现了专利侵权诉讼中认定侵权后不判决停止侵权的判例;从知识产权法理和法经济学的角度来看,不判决停止侵权具有合理性,并可通过法律规定进行相应的补偿和救济。
專利侵權訴訟中,一般情況下,法院都會判決停止侵權。但由于專利產品的特殊性,有時停止侵權的判決會對公共利益和他人利益造成嚴重損害。在司法實踐中,已經齣現瞭專利侵權訴訟中認定侵權後不判決停止侵權的判例;從知識產權法理和法經濟學的角度來看,不判決停止侵權具有閤理性,併可通過法律規定進行相應的補償和救濟。
전리침권소송중,일반정황하,법원도회판결정지침권。단유우전리산품적특수성,유시정지침권적판결회대공공이익화타인이익조성엄중손해。재사법실천중,이경출현료전리침권소송중인정침권후불판결정지침권적판례;종지식산권법리화법경제학적각도래간,불판결정지침권구유합이성,병가통과법률규정진행상응적보상화구제。
In patent infringement lawsuit, cessations of infringement are always supported in general situation. However, because of the particular characteristic of patent product, sometimes cessation of in- fringement will cause serious damage to the public or others~ interest. In judicial practice, after patent in- fringement had been confirmed, some cases that cessation of infringement is not supported have emerged. In the view of the aspect of intellectual property law principles and law economy, it is rational not to sup- port to cessation of infringement, with a legally reasonable compensation instead.