经济社会体制比较
經濟社會體製比較
경제사회체제비교
Comparative Economic and Social Systems
2014年
2期
178~193
,共null页
政治信任 制度主义 文化主义 中观理论
政治信任 製度主義 文化主義 中觀理論
정치신임 제도주의 문화주의 중관이론
Political Trust ; Institutionalism; Culturalism; Meso - theory
学术界对政治信任来源的解释一直存在着文化主义和制度主义两种路径。文章试图将其整合进一个互动与修正的政治信任的中观理论分析框架中。文章认为,是否强调传统价值或现代化条件下的自由民主或后物质主义价值,是影响个人对政治体制和机构产生信任的基础性条件。这种基础性条件是由宏观社会文化在个人成长过程中塑造的。而对制度和机构的绩效评价,则是根据微观的个人、经济、社会、政治信息作出的。具有价值倾向的个人对各类政治信息进行加工、优先排序与调试,形成了对政治体制和机构的信任。文章在横向上区分特定性与弥散性的政治信任,并利用“亚洲民主动态调查”第一波和第三波数据,对理论假设加以检验。实证结果基本支持了互动与修正政治信任模型的假设。中国公众的政治信任表现为在受价值观倾向、人际信任等宏观文化主义因素影响的背景下,对微观上接收到的信任对象(体制和机构)的“制度主义”特征如绩效、透明度、廉洁作出的回应与修正。
學術界對政治信任來源的解釋一直存在著文化主義和製度主義兩種路徑。文章試圖將其整閤進一箇互動與脩正的政治信任的中觀理論分析框架中。文章認為,是否彊調傳統價值或現代化條件下的自由民主或後物質主義價值,是影響箇人對政治體製和機構產生信任的基礎性條件。這種基礎性條件是由宏觀社會文化在箇人成長過程中塑造的。而對製度和機構的績效評價,則是根據微觀的箇人、經濟、社會、政治信息作齣的。具有價值傾嚮的箇人對各類政治信息進行加工、優先排序與調試,形成瞭對政治體製和機構的信任。文章在橫嚮上區分特定性與瀰散性的政治信任,併利用“亞洲民主動態調查”第一波和第三波數據,對理論假設加以檢驗。實證結果基本支持瞭互動與脩正政治信任模型的假設。中國公衆的政治信任錶現為在受價值觀傾嚮、人際信任等宏觀文化主義因素影響的揹景下,對微觀上接收到的信任對象(體製和機構)的“製度主義”特徵如績效、透明度、廉潔作齣的迴應與脩正。
학술계대정치신임래원적해석일직존재착문화주의화제도주의량충로경。문장시도장기정합진일개호동여수정적정치신임적중관이론분석광가중。문장인위,시부강조전통개치혹현대화조건하적자유민주혹후물질주의개치,시영향개인대정치체제화궤구산생신임적기출성조건。저충기출성조건시유굉관사회문화재개인성장과정중소조적。이대제도화궤구적적효평개,칙시근거미관적개인、경제、사회、정치신식작출적。구유개치경향적개인대각류정치신식진행가공、우선배서여조시,형성료대정치체제화궤구적신임。문장재횡향상구분특정성여미산성적정치신임,병이용“아주민주동태조사”제일파화제삼파수거,대이론가설가이검험。실증결과기본지지료호동여수정정치신임모형적가설。중국공음적정치신임표현위재수개치관경향、인제신임등굉관문화주의인소영향적배경하,대미관상접수도적신임대상(체제화궤구)적“제도주의”특정여적효、투명도、렴길작출적회응여수정。
Cultural and institutional explanations of political trust have been intensively examined by scholars. This paper integrates them into a meso - level theory and analyzes political trust as an interactive and revisionist process. We argue that social and political values received from early stage socialization form the psychological foundation on which individuals process and respond to evaluations of institutional performances. Such an inter- active process determines how much an individual citizen trusts a political institution or political system. Contin- uous inflow of political information also means individuals will revise their disposition regarding how trustworthy the political objective (institution or system) is. Based on Waves One and Three data from the Asian Barometer Survey, we examine longitudinal changes in Chinese people's political trust in specific institutions and their gen- eral political trust. The empirical results support this model of interactive and revisionist political trust. Specif- ically, Chinese citizens' political trust appears to be defined by political culture as manifested in individual's value orientation, but it is constantly revised when citizens respond to the regime and institutions' performance, such as their economic performance, transparency, responsiveness, and cleanness.