海南大学学报:人文社会科学版
海南大學學報:人文社會科學版
해남대학학보:인문사회과학판
Humanities & Social Sciences Journal of Hainan University
2014年
2期
18~23
,共null页
施特劳斯 雅可比 启蒙 泛神论之争 虚无主义
施特勞斯 雅可比 啟矇 汎神論之爭 虛無主義
시특로사 아가비 계몽 범신론지쟁 허무주의
Leo Strauss ; Friedrich Heinrich Jacobi ; Enlightenment; pantheism controversy; nihilism
施特劳斯之所以看重雅可比,主要在于雅可比对启蒙哲学的尖锐批判。雅可比认为,启蒙不过是一种理智上的僭政,其教条程度毫不逊色于大公教会,堪称“耶稣会派和哲学上的教权”。正是雅可比对启蒙哲学的致命批判,使施特劳斯看清了现代理性主义的本相。艾尔特曼的指控并非出于对思想自由的哲学热情,而是出于启蒙教士的政治狂热,他对施特劳斯的指控跟苏格拉底所受的指控异曲同工。
施特勞斯之所以看重雅可比,主要在于雅可比對啟矇哲學的尖銳批判。雅可比認為,啟矇不過是一種理智上的僭政,其教條程度毫不遜色于大公教會,堪稱“耶穌會派和哲學上的教權”。正是雅可比對啟矇哲學的緻命批判,使施特勞斯看清瞭現代理性主義的本相。艾爾特曼的指控併非齣于對思想自由的哲學熱情,而是齣于啟矇教士的政治狂熱,他對施特勞斯的指控跟囌格拉底所受的指控異麯同工。
시특로사지소이간중아가비,주요재우아가비대계몽철학적첨예비판。아가비인위,계몽불과시일충리지상적참정,기교조정도호불손색우대공교회,감칭“야소회파화철학상적교권”。정시아가비대계몽철학적치명비판,사시특로사간청료현대이성주의적본상。애이특만적지공병비출우대사상자유적철학열정,이시출우계몽교사적정치광열,타대시특로사적지공근소격랍저소수적지공이곡동공。
What Leo Strauss values Friedrich Heinrich Jacobi mainly lies in Jacobi' s sharp critique of Enlight- enment philosophy. Jacobi believes that Enlightenment represents just a form of intellectual tyranny and its dog- matism is no less than the Catholic Church, which is nothing more than a disguised "Jesuitism and the philo- sophical magisterium". Through Jacobi' s fatal criticism on Enlightenment philosophy, Leo Strauss sees through the nature of modem rationalism. William H. F. Ahman' s accusation of Leo Strauss is not from the philosophi- cal passion for freedom of thinking, but the political fanaticism of an Enlightenment priest, which is hence simi- lar to that made to Socrates.