重庆理工大学学报：社会科学版
重慶理工大學學報：社會科學版
중경리공대학학보：사회과학판
Journal of Chongqing Institute of Technology
2014年
3期
17~21
,共null页
法律推理 逻辑规则 实践理性 位移
法律推理 邏輯規則 實踐理性 位移
법률추리 라집규칙 실천이성 위이
legal reasoning; logical rules ; practical reason ; displacement
法律推理过程包含着权力与利益、应然与实然、确定性与妥当性、客观解释与主观解释、逻辑与价值、语言与事件、思维与表达、认知与行动等诸多矛盾.在司法能动主义与司法克制主义、自然法学与分析法学、实证主义与现实主义、分析哲学与经验哲学的碰撞中,法律已经由文本所体现的规范层面转向法律施行的实践层面,法律推理已经由“逻辑独白”位移到“实践理性”.
法律推理過程包含著權力與利益、應然與實然、確定性與妥噹性、客觀解釋與主觀解釋、邏輯與價值、語言與事件、思維與錶達、認知與行動等諸多矛盾.在司法能動主義與司法剋製主義、自然法學與分析法學、實證主義與現實主義、分析哲學與經驗哲學的踫撞中,法律已經由文本所體現的規範層麵轉嚮法律施行的實踐層麵,法律推理已經由“邏輯獨白”位移到“實踐理性”.
법률추리과정포함착권력여이익、응연여실연、학정성여타당성、객관해석여주관해석、라집여개치、어언여사건、사유여표체、인지여행동등제다모순.재사법능동주의여사법극제주의、자연법학여분석법학、실증주의여현실주의、분석철학여경험철학적팽당중,법률이경유문본소체현적규범층면전향법률시행적실천층면,법률추리이경유“라집독백”위이도“실천이성”.
Legal reasoning process consists of power and interests, and the reality of course, certainty and proper, objective interpretation and subjective interpretation, logic and values, language and e-vents, thought and expression, cognition and action, and many contradictions. In collisions of judicial activism and judicial restraint, natural law and analysis of law, positivism and realism, analytic phi- losophy and experience philosophy, the law has been reflected by the text normative level steering laws in force practical level. And it has been reviewed by legal reasoning ＂logical monologue＂ to ＂practical reason＂ for displacement.
