河北法学
河北法學
하북법학
Hebei Law Science
2014年
6期
120~126
,共null页
刑法 裁判客观性 形式解释 实质解释 罪刑法定原则
刑法 裁判客觀性 形式解釋 實質解釋 罪刑法定原則
형법 재판객관성 형식해석 실질해석 죄형법정원칙
criminal law; judicial objectivity; the formalistic interpretation theory; the substantial interpretation theory; the principle of legality
随着后现代法学的兴起，司法裁判的客观性面临着种种挑战，但是客观性仍有重大意义，学术界也适时提出了拯救客观性的命题。裁判客观性的基本特征要求法律的明确性、行为的可预测性以及排斥法官的主观臆断。折射在刑法解释上，形式解释贯彻罪刑法定原则更彻底，类推解释和扩大解释的边界也更明晰。在解释方法的位阶排序上，形式解释倡导文理解释比实质解释的目的解释论更契合客观性的基本要求。
隨著後現代法學的興起，司法裁判的客觀性麵臨著種種挑戰，但是客觀性仍有重大意義，學術界也適時提齣瞭拯救客觀性的命題。裁判客觀性的基本特徵要求法律的明確性、行為的可預測性以及排斥法官的主觀臆斷。摺射在刑法解釋上，形式解釋貫徹罪刑法定原則更徹底，類推解釋和擴大解釋的邊界也更明晰。在解釋方法的位階排序上，形式解釋倡導文理解釋比實質解釋的目的解釋論更契閤客觀性的基本要求。
수착후현대법학적흥기，사법재판적객관성면림착충충도전，단시객관성잉유중대의의，학술계야괄시제출료증구객관성적명제。재판객관성적기본특정요구법률적명학성、행위적가예측성이급배척법관적주관억단。절사재형법해석상，형식해석관철죄형법정원칙경철저，유추해석화확대해석적변계야경명석。재해석방법적위계배서상，형식해석창도문리해석비실질해석적목적해석론경계합객관성적기본요구。
With the prosperity of post-modern jurisprudence, the objectivity of the law faces enormous challenges , and ultimately academic circle put forward to save it. The basic characteristics of judicial objectivity demands legal certainty, predictability of behavior and the exclusion of subjective judges. Refraction on interpretation in criminal law, formalistic interpretation theory implement the principle of legality. And the boundary of Analogical interpretation and Expand Explanation is more clear. On the interpretation method sorting, Literal rule by formalistic interpretation theory conform to judicial objectivity in a larger sense than the purpose explanation by the substantial interpretation theory.
