河北法学
河北法學
하북법학
Hebei Law Science
2014年
6期
127~135
,共null页
铁路运营安全事故罪 渎职罪 公务性 监管过失责任 竞合
鐵路運營安全事故罪 瀆職罪 公務性 鑑管過失責任 競閤
철로운영안전사고죄 독직죄 공무성 감관과실책임 경합
crime of railway safty accident; crimes of dereliction of duty; official duty ;supervisory negligence liability ; overlap of articles of law
时有发生的铁路运营安全事故中,由于相关罪名认定可能存在竞合、刑罚处置可能存在空档的情形,故肩负安全监管职责的管理人员与铁路一线职工的刑责追究问题需细致厘析。在铁路系统曾经的“政企不分”“独立司法”和铁路司法改革破冰,铁道部撤并、新设国家铁路局及中国铁路总公司,希求“政企分开”的大部制改革背景下,铁路检察实务打击渎职类行为时对犯罪主体问题应审慎甄别。
時有髮生的鐵路運營安全事故中,由于相關罪名認定可能存在競閤、刑罰處置可能存在空檔的情形,故肩負安全鑑管職責的管理人員與鐵路一線職工的刑責追究問題需細緻釐析。在鐵路繫統曾經的“政企不分”“獨立司法”和鐵路司法改革破冰,鐵道部撤併、新設國傢鐵路跼及中國鐵路總公司,希求“政企分開”的大部製改革揹景下,鐵路檢察實務打擊瀆職類行為時對犯罪主體問題應審慎甄彆。
시유발생적철로운영안전사고중,유우상관죄명인정가능존재경합、형벌처치가능존재공당적정형,고견부안전감관직책적관리인원여철로일선직공적형책추구문제수세치전석。재철로계통증경적“정기불분”“독립사법”화철로사법개혁파빙,철도부철병、신설국가철로국급중국철로총공사,희구“정기분개”적대부제개혁배경하,철로검찰실무타격독직류행위시대범죄주체문제응심신견별。
As for the accidents occured during railway operation from time to time, since there might be overlaps of articles of law when cognizing crimes and blank gaps of articles of law when conducting punishments, it is quite neccessary to figure out the accountability of those managers who shoudering the security regulatory responsibility and those staffs who working at the front-line. In the railway system, under the circumstance of "Integrating Government Functions with Enterprise" and "Judicial Independence" , the icebreaking of reformation in railway justice, the removing and combinating of railway departments, the establishing of The National Railway Bureau and China Railway Corporation, as well as the Super- Ministries Reforming for the purpose of " Separating Government Functions from Enterprises", the determination of subjects of crime, when railway judicial institutionsfight against crimes of dereliction of duty, should be conducted scrupulously.