西南交通大学学报:社会科学版
西南交通大學學報:社會科學版
서남교통대학학보:사회과학판
Journal of Southwest Jiaotong Universit(Social Science Edition)
2014年
3期
53~58
,共null页
普遍语用学 交往有效性条件 经验论 先验论 转喻
普遍語用學 交往有效性條件 經驗論 先驗論 轉喻
보편어용학 교왕유효성조건 경험론 선험론 전유
universal pragmatics ; validity claims ; empiricism ; apriorism ; metonymy
哈贝马斯的普遍语用学理论设定了描述客观世界的真实性、在社会世界中建立人际关系的合理性和表达个人主观世界的真诚性三个交往有效性条件,这解决了传统哲学的经验论和先验论中主客二元对立的问题,但是没有论证交往有效性条件的基础。转喻理论可以解决这一问题,因为陈述型的语言使用所要求的真实性往往是基于指称式转喻的相对真实性的,表现型语言使用中的真诚性是以言语行为转喻为基础的,互动型语言使用中所要求的合理性则兼有述谓式转喻和言语行为转喻的基础。
哈貝馬斯的普遍語用學理論設定瞭描述客觀世界的真實性、在社會世界中建立人際關繫的閤理性和錶達箇人主觀世界的真誠性三箇交往有效性條件,這解決瞭傳統哲學的經驗論和先驗論中主客二元對立的問題,但是沒有論證交往有效性條件的基礎。轉喻理論可以解決這一問題,因為陳述型的語言使用所要求的真實性往往是基于指稱式轉喻的相對真實性的,錶現型語言使用中的真誠性是以言語行為轉喻為基礎的,互動型語言使用中所要求的閤理性則兼有述謂式轉喻和言語行為轉喻的基礎。
합패마사적보편어용학이론설정료묘술객관세계적진실성、재사회세계중건립인제관계적합이성화표체개인주관세계적진성성삼개교왕유효성조건,저해결료전통철학적경험론화선험론중주객이원대립적문제,단시몰유론증교왕유효성조건적기출。전유이론가이해결저일문제,인위진술형적어언사용소요구적진실성왕왕시기우지칭식전유적상대진실성적,표현형어언사용중적진성성시이언어행위전유위기출적,호동형어언사용중소요구적합이성칙겸유술위식전유화언어행위전유적기출。
The three communication validity conditions set by Habermas' theory of universal pragmatics give a solution to a priori-empirical paradox deep-rooted in the traditional philosophy. These conditions include the truth claim of representing physical world, the rightness claim of establishing legitimate interpersonal relationship in the social world and the truthfulness claim in the disclosure of speaker's subjectivity. However, the basis for such conditions is not specified. Actually such basis is metonymy, in which one uses a part of something to refer to the whole, or uses the whole to refer to one part of it. Metonymy can be divided into proposition metonymy (including referential metonymy and predication metonymy) and speech act metonymy. The truth claims of assertive use of language are the relative truth based on referential metonymy. The truthfulness claims in the expressive use of language are based on speech act metonymy, and the rightness claims in the regulative use of language have the basis of both predication metonymy and speech act metonymy.