南昌大学学报:人文社会科学版
南昌大學學報:人文社會科學版
남창대학학보:인문사회과학판
Journal of Nanchang University(Humanities and Social Sciences)
2014年
3期
120~124
,共null页
司法新闻 报道限制 司法独立
司法新聞 報道限製 司法獨立
사법신문 보도한제 사법독립
coverage restrictions ;judicial news ;judicial independence
为了防止媒介审判,英国和美国均对媒体的司法新闻报道进行了限制。相比而言,英国采用的是一种直接限制措施,倾向于限制媒体对未决案件中当事人信息的披露、对案情的报道和庭审现场的录音摄像;美国采用的是一种间接限制措施,倾向于限制诉讼参与人发言和调整审判活动等,主要是通过限制潜在消息来源而对媒体报道进行限制。在英美,对媒体的这种报道限制是司法公开的例外,要受到严格的司法审查。
為瞭防止媒介審判,英國和美國均對媒體的司法新聞報道進行瞭限製。相比而言,英國採用的是一種直接限製措施,傾嚮于限製媒體對未決案件中噹事人信息的披露、對案情的報道和庭審現場的錄音攝像;美國採用的是一種間接限製措施,傾嚮于限製訴訟參與人髮言和調整審判活動等,主要是通過限製潛在消息來源而對媒體報道進行限製。在英美,對媒體的這種報道限製是司法公開的例外,要受到嚴格的司法審查。
위료방지매개심판,영국화미국균대매체적사법신문보도진행료한제。상비이언,영국채용적시일충직접한제조시,경향우한제매체대미결안건중당사인신식적피로、대안정적보도화정심현장적록음섭상;미국채용적시일충간접한제조시,경향우한제소송삼여인발언화조정심판활동등,주요시통과한제잠재소식래원이대매체보도진행한제。재영미,대매체적저충보도한제시사법공개적예외,요수도엄격적사법심사。
In order to prevent the trial by media, laws and regulations restrict the media' s reporting of legal proceedings in the United Kingdom and the United States. By contrast, British law is a direct restriction;it tends to limit the disclosure and the leak of unsettled law case and ban cameras and electronic coverage in courtrooms American law is an indirect restriction, it tends to limit the speech of participants in the proceedings and adjust trial activities, and it limits the media coverage mainly by restricting the potential news sources. The restrictions on the media coverage are the exception of judicial transparency and must be subjected to strict judicial scrutiny in Britain and America.