河北法学
河北法學
하북법학
Hebei Law Science
2014年
7期
185~190
,共null页
仲裁 管辖权理论 自裁管辖权 仲裁程序 效率
仲裁 管轄權理論 自裁管轄權 仲裁程序 效率
중재 관할권이론 자재관할권 중재정서 효솔
arbitration ; general jurisdiction ; self-adjudicating jurisdiction ; arbitration proceeding; efficiency
自裁管辖权,即仲裁庭有对其自身的管辖权和仲裁协议的效力作出裁决的权利。这一现代仲裁的重要成就,突破了传统管辖权理论的束缚,已被国际、国内仲裁立法与实践广泛采用。自裁管辖理论适应了仲裁实践和经济社会发展的需要。其目的不在于排斥法院的司法管辖权、赋予仲裁庭决定自己管辖权的权力,而仅仅是为了延迟司法机关对仲裁程序的干预时间,在一定程度上保证正在进行的仲裁程序不被打断,从而有效防止一方当事人恶意延宕仲裁程序,极大提高了仲裁的效率。我国法律对仲裁机构的自裁管辖权做出了特殊规定,但这种规定有违当事人的意愿、不符仲裁的效率原则、造成仲裁权分离,并且在实践中凸显出较多问题。对于这些弊端,国内的仲裁机构已经通过对仲裁规则的修改予以缓解,但对其根本的解决,仍应通过修改现行的仲裁法来实现。
自裁管轄權,即仲裁庭有對其自身的管轄權和仲裁協議的效力作齣裁決的權利。這一現代仲裁的重要成就,突破瞭傳統管轄權理論的束縳,已被國際、國內仲裁立法與實踐廣汎採用。自裁管轄理論適應瞭仲裁實踐和經濟社會髮展的需要。其目的不在于排斥法院的司法管轄權、賦予仲裁庭決定自己管轄權的權力,而僅僅是為瞭延遲司法機關對仲裁程序的榦預時間,在一定程度上保證正在進行的仲裁程序不被打斷,從而有效防止一方噹事人噁意延宕仲裁程序,極大提高瞭仲裁的效率。我國法律對仲裁機構的自裁管轄權做齣瞭特殊規定,但這種規定有違噹事人的意願、不符仲裁的效率原則、造成仲裁權分離,併且在實踐中凸顯齣較多問題。對于這些弊耑,國內的仲裁機構已經通過對仲裁規則的脩改予以緩解,但對其根本的解決,仍應通過脩改現行的仲裁法來實現。
자재관할권,즉중재정유대기자신적관할권화중재협의적효력작출재결적권리。저일현대중재적중요성취,돌파료전통관할권이론적속박,이피국제、국내중재입법여실천엄범채용。자재관할이론괄응료중재실천화경제사회발전적수요。기목적불재우배척법원적사법관할권、부여중재정결정자기관할권적권력,이부부시위료연지사법궤관대중재정서적간예시간,재일정정도상보증정재진행적중재정서불피타단,종이유효방지일방당사인악의연탕중재정서,겁대제고료중재적효솔。아국법률대중재궤구적자재관할권주출료특수규정,단저충규정유위당사인적의원、불부중재적효솔원칙、조성중재권분리,병차재실천중철현출교다문제。대우저사폐단,국내적중재궤구이경통과대중재규칙적수개여이완해,단대기근본적해결,잉응통과수개현행적중재법래실현。
It has been widely adopted that,the arbitration agreement's effectiveness, as well as its jurisdiction by International and domestic legislations could be decided by the arbitral tribunal. The theory is considered a great success in arbitration field. According the theory, judge still entitled to determine the final effect of the arbitration agreement. The purpose of the theory is not to exclude the jurisdiction of the courts but to delay court intervening in the arbitration proceeding, which greatly improve the efficiency of the arbitration proceedings. China Arbitration Laws, to some extent, provides that the arbitration organ determine the validity of the arbitration agreement, which has a lot of drawbacks, but the fundamental solution to the problem should be achieved by amending the Arbitration Act.