心理学报
心理學報
심이학보
Acta Psychologica Sinica
2014年
9期
1261~1270
,共null页
张文嘉 李楠 关少伟 王穗苹
張文嘉 李楠 關少偉 王穗蘋
장문가 리남 관소위 왕수평
副中央凹 语义提取 预视效应
副中央凹 語義提取 預視效應
부중앙요 어의제취 예시효응
parafoveal; semantic extraction; preview benefit effects
书面语言阅读过程中,关于读者能否提取预视词汇的语义信息,以往的研究仍有争议。鉴于边界技术在研究该问题时具有无法严格控制预视词呈现时间等一些局限性,近年来有研究者利用ERPs技术结合伴侧RSVP范式对拼音语言中的语义预视效应进行研究。本研究首次将这一方法应用到中文句子阅读中,并对实验材料进行了更严格的控制,保证关键屏(目标名词位于右侧副中央凹处)内容在实验条件间完全相同,避免以往类似研究中关键词自身属性信息对实验结果产生干扰。ERPs数据分析发现,在关键屏呈现后,语义违背相比合理条件诱发了更大的N400成分,而关键后屏(目标名词位于中央凹处)呈现后,两种条件问的N400成分无显著差异。该结果支持中文句子阅读中预视词汇语义信息可以得到提取,并参与随后的语义整合过程。
書麵語言閱讀過程中,關于讀者能否提取預視詞彙的語義信息,以往的研究仍有爭議。鑒于邊界技術在研究該問題時具有無法嚴格控製預視詞呈現時間等一些跼限性,近年來有研究者利用ERPs技術結閤伴側RSVP範式對拼音語言中的語義預視效應進行研究。本研究首次將這一方法應用到中文句子閱讀中,併對實驗材料進行瞭更嚴格的控製,保證關鍵屏(目標名詞位于右側副中央凹處)內容在實驗條件間完全相同,避免以往類似研究中關鍵詞自身屬性信息對實驗結果產生榦擾。ERPs數據分析髮現,在關鍵屏呈現後,語義違揹相比閤理條件誘髮瞭更大的N400成分,而關鍵後屏(目標名詞位于中央凹處)呈現後,兩種條件問的N400成分無顯著差異。該結果支持中文句子閱讀中預視詞彙語義信息可以得到提取,併參與隨後的語義整閤過程。
서면어언열독과정중,관우독자능부제취예시사회적어의신식,이왕적연구잉유쟁의。감우변계기술재연구해문제시구유무법엄격공제예시사정현시간등일사국한성,근년래유연구자이용ERPs기술결합반측RSVP범식대병음어언중적어의예시효응진행연구。본연구수차장저일방법응용도중문구자열독중,병대실험재료진행료경엄격적공제,보증관건병(목표명사위우우측부중앙요처)내용재실험조건간완전상동,피면이왕유사연구중관건사자신속성신식대실험결과산생간우。ERPs수거분석발현,재관건병정현후,어의위배상비합리조건유발료경대적N400성분,이관건후병(목표명사위우중앙요처)정현후,량충조건문적N400성분무현저차이。해결과지지중문구자열독중예시사회어의신식가이득도제취,병삼여수후적어의정합과정。
Previous studies have confirmed that readers can obtain sub-lexical information (e.g., orthographic or phonological) from the parafovea during reading. However, no consensus has been reached as to whether semantic information can also be extracted from the parafoveal word. A possible explanation for this controversy may be the limitations of the boundary paradigm in eye-tracking reading experiments, which have been the main methodology used in previous studies. For instance, the duration of parafoveal word viewing cannot be held constant across conditions in the boundary paradigm. Thus, in this study, an ERPs paradigm using rapid serial visual presentation (RSVP) with flankers was used to study extraction of semantic information from the parafoveal word in the reading of Chinese sentences.
A total of 84 sets of Chinese sentences were constructed for this study. Unlike previous studies, in each set of sentences, the two-character verbs were manipulated, yielding a congruent or incongruent context with the target single-character noun that appeared 4 or 5 characters after the verbs. Thus the critical trials (containing the target noun as the right flanker) were the same across congruent and incongruent conditions. Each sentence was presented character by character at fixation, flanked 2~ bilaterally by the preceding character (n-l) on the left and the next character (n+l) on the right. Each viewing consisted of three characters presented on the screen for 100 ms with an inter-stimuli interval (ISI) of 400 ms. Twenty-four participants' ERPs were recorded individually with 40 tin electrodes (10-20 System) in a sound-attenuating, electrically shielded booth. The EEG and EOG signals were sampled at 500 Hz and filtered digitally offline with a 0.02 to 30 Hz band pass. Epochs of interest were selected time-locked to the onset of the critical trials with a 200 ms pre-onset baseline window and a 1000 ms window after onset. Mean ERPs amplitudes from 300-450 ms and 800-950 ms were computed for each participant and tested for significance using ANOVA.
A more negative N400 component was found between 300 and 450ms when the sentence context was incongruent than when it was congruent with the right flanker. Furthermore, no significant differences between the two conditions were found between 800 and 950ms, which was the time window of the N400 effect when the target noun was fixated foveally. Since the critical trials were the same across conditions and different lexical properties in the parafovea were avoided, the only manipulation was the semantic congruence of the target noun with the prior context. Thus the significant difference in the N400 component between 300 and 450ms suggests that semantic extraction from the parafoveal word exists during the first 100 ms of current word fixation in Chinese sentence reading. These results suggest that the semantic information of a preview word may be processed in parallel with the fixated word, which supports the view of GAG models (such as SWIFT). Together with the results of previous studies, the present study also demonstrates that the flanker-RSVP ERPs paradigm may be a suitable method for the study of parafoveal processing during sentence reading.