社会
社會
사회
Society
2014年
6期
98~113
,共null页
行政发包制 政府治理 科层制 政治锦标赛
行政髮包製 政府治理 科層製 政治錦標賽
행정발포제 정부치리 과층제 정치금표새
administrative subcontract, government governance, bureaucracy, political tournament
本文对周雪光、张静、曹正汉和冯仕政四位教授的评论文章进行了回应。笔者的回应侧重在各位评论入提出的带有批判性质的意见和建议上。笔者和评论入的分歧主要集中在行政发包制的界定、内涵和形成原因、统治风险的内涵和影响、发包人和承包人的权力配置等问题上,对于这些问题,笔者试图做进一步的澄清和解释。鉴于评论人的批评建议,本文也讨论了行政发包制未来可以进一步扩展和完善的领域。最后,笔者提出了一个好的理论的三个标准,并讨论了跨学科交流对于发展好理论的重要意义。
本文對週雪光、張靜、曹正漢和馮仕政四位教授的評論文章進行瞭迴應。筆者的迴應側重在各位評論入提齣的帶有批判性質的意見和建議上。筆者和評論入的分歧主要集中在行政髮包製的界定、內涵和形成原因、統治風險的內涵和影響、髮包人和承包人的權力配置等問題上,對于這些問題,筆者試圖做進一步的澄清和解釋。鑒于評論人的批評建議,本文也討論瞭行政髮包製未來可以進一步擴展和完善的領域。最後,筆者提齣瞭一箇好的理論的三箇標準,併討論瞭跨學科交流對于髮展好理論的重要意義。
본문대주설광、장정、조정한화풍사정사위교수적평논문장진행료회응。필자적회응측중재각위평론입제출적대유비판성질적의견화건의상。필자화평론입적분기주요집중재행정발포제적계정、내함화형성원인、통치풍험적내함화영향、발포인화승포인적권력배치등문제상,대우저사문제,필자시도주진일보적징청화해석。감우평론인적비평건의,본문야토론료행정발포제미래가이진일보확전화완선적영역。최후,필자제출료일개호적이론적삼개표준,병토론료과학과교류대우발전호이론적중요의의。
This piece serves as a response to the comments on my paper "Administrative Subcontract" made by Zhou Xueguang, Zhang Jing, Cao Zhenghan, and Feng Shizheng. My reply focuses both on their critical comments and suggestions. Our differences center on such issues as the definition, content,and causes of administrative subcontract system, the definition and implications of ruling risks, and authority allocation between the principal and the agent. In the reply I try to clarify the confusions and explain the reasons why we differ in these matters and indicate my stance. Following the commentators' critical comments and suggestions,I also discuss the possibilities and directions for further improvement of the administrative subcontract theory. In the conclusion, I propose three criteria for a good theory and highlight the importance of interdisciplinary academic exchange and interaction in developing a good theory.