社会学评论
社會學評論
사회학평론
2015年
2期
16~33
,共null页
涉诉信访 基本类型 治理
涉訴信訪 基本類型 治理
섭소신방 기본류형 치리
litigation petition; types; governance
涉诉信访的四种基本类型是谋利型上访、维权型上访、无理型上访和说理型上访。当事人采取的涉诉信访策略包括越级访、倒逼策略、闹访和缠访等等。法院治理涉诉信访的策略有:做思想工作、发放司法救助金、包案责任制、源头治理等等。信访嵌入审判结构具有双重作用:一方面,赋予当事人进入维稳系统进行博弈的权利;另一方面,成为诉讼程序无限延伸的制度通道。由此,基层法院出现“息诉”和“歇访”的辩证律,即所采取的一系列“息访”手段都只能起到暂时的“歇访”作用,而不能彻底化解矛盾。
涉訴信訪的四種基本類型是謀利型上訪、維權型上訪、無理型上訪和說理型上訪。噹事人採取的涉訴信訪策略包括越級訪、倒逼策略、鬧訪和纏訪等等。法院治理涉訴信訪的策略有:做思想工作、髮放司法救助金、包案責任製、源頭治理等等。信訪嵌入審判結構具有雙重作用:一方麵,賦予噹事人進入維穩繫統進行博弈的權利;另一方麵,成為訴訟程序無限延伸的製度通道。由此,基層法院齣現“息訴”和“歇訪”的辯證律,即所採取的一繫列“息訪”手段都隻能起到暫時的“歇訪”作用,而不能徹底化解矛盾。
섭소신방적사충기본류형시모리형상방、유권형상방、무리형상방화설리형상방。당사인채취적섭소신방책략포괄월급방、도핍책략、료방화전방등등。법원치리섭소신방적책략유:주사상공작、발방사법구조금、포안책임제、원두치리등등。신방감입심판결구구유쌍중작용:일방면,부여당사인진입유은계통진행박혁적권리;령일방면,성위소송정서무한연신적제도통도。유차,기층법원출현“식소”화“헐방”적변증률,즉소채취적일계렬“식방”수단도지능기도잠시적“헐방”작용,이불능철저화해모순。
There are mainly four types of the Litigation Involved Complaint Letters and Visits: inter- ests-seeking petition, safeguard rights petition, unreasonable petition and reasoning petition. Litigation petition strategy adopted by the parties including leapfrog visit, forced strategy, noisy and wrapped visits and so on. The governance strategies of court have ideological work, judicial assistance payments, accountability package case, source control and so on. The petition embedded the trial structure has a dual role: on one hand, it endows the party rights entering the system stability; on the other hand, it becomes the chan- nel of the infinite extend of the lawsuit procedure. Thus, the grassroots court have the dialectical rate of "break with the petition" and "rest the petition", that is a series means of the "break with the petition" can only play a role of "rest the petition", but can not completely resolve the contradictions