CAJ | 학술논문

在落实新修订的《刑事诉讼法》的侦查实践中，公安机关经常受到上级行政命令的左右，而相关的司法解释也造成了法典本身适用的无序化，使得刑事诉讼法的实施效果大打折扣。在法律规范理论的语境下，问题的产生在于破坏了既有的合理的法律位阶体系，进而破坏了由法律位阶体系所确定的法律规范效力层级，最终造成了法律适用的混乱。依据法律位阶理论分析，会发现行政命令存在着非法解释的危险，而司法解释则存在着越权扩充的弊病和裹抉部门利益、混淆立法主体的恶果。应设计解决方案，修复被破坏的法律效力层级，使《刑事诉讼法》得到良好的运行和操作。
재락실신수정적《형사소송법》적정사실천중，공안궤관경상수도상급행정명령적좌우，이상관적사법해석야조성료법전본신괄용적무서화，사득형사소송법적실시효과대타절구。재법률규범이론적어경하，문제적산생재우파배료기유적합리적법률위계체계，진이파배료유법률위계체계소학정적법률규범효력층급，최종조성료법률괄용적혼란。의거법률위계이론분석，회발현행정명령존재착비법해석적위험，이사법해석칙존재착월권확충적폐병화과결부문이익、혼효입법주체적악과。응설계해결방안，수복피파배적법률효력층급，사《형사소송법》득도량호적운행화조작。
In implementing the newly-revised criminal procedure in public security detection practice, the public security or- gan frequently receives the higher authority administrative order, but the judicial interpretation concerned has led to the disorder as to the application of the law. In the context of legal standard, the emergence of the problem lies in the destruction of the exis- tent rational legislative ranking system. Based on the legislative ranking theoretical analysis, the administrative order has the problem of illegal explanation, but the judicial interpretation has the problem of exceeding authority to expand, coercing the de- partment benefit, and confusing legislative bodies. Proper solutions should be made out, and the damaged legislative ranking sys- tem should be mended.