中南大学学报:社会科学版
中南大學學報:社會科學版
중남대학학보:사회과학판
Journal of Central South Huiversity: Social Science
2015年
2期
80~85
,共null页
地役权 地方性 相邻关系 公共地役权 意义回归
地役權 地方性 相鄰關繫 公共地役權 意義迴歸
지역권 지방성 상린관계 공공지역권 의의회귀
easement; native nature; neighboring relations; public easement; meanings regression
地役权概念被滥用是当今学术环境下法律概念被滥用的典型之一。地役权概念实际上是一个具有地方性的法律概念,有其确定的法教义学意义并应恪守作为私法权利的规范意旨。不宜将基于比较法研究发现的、局部特征类似于地役权的多种异质规则全部归结于地役权范畴,从而使得这一私法概念膨胀为横跨公私法的万能法律工具。当前较为迫切的学术任务,是给地役权瘦身,尤其是要清除“公共地役权”这一似是而非的学术概念造成的地役权虚胖现象,让地役权回归其本质。
地役權概唸被濫用是噹今學術環境下法律概唸被濫用的典型之一。地役權概唸實際上是一箇具有地方性的法律概唸,有其確定的法教義學意義併應恪守作為私法權利的規範意旨。不宜將基于比較法研究髮現的、跼部特徵類似于地役權的多種異質規則全部歸結于地役權範疇,從而使得這一私法概唸膨脹為橫跨公私法的萬能法律工具。噹前較為迫切的學術任務,是給地役權瘦身,尤其是要清除“公共地役權”這一似是而非的學術概唸造成的地役權虛胖現象,讓地役權迴歸其本質。
지역권개념피람용시당금학술배경하법률개념피람용적전형지일。지역권개념실제상시일개구유지방성적법률개념,유기학정적법교의학의의병응각수작위사법권리적규범의지。불의장기우비교법연구발현적、국부특정유사우지역권적다충이질규칙전부귀결우지역권범주,종이사득저일사법개념팽창위횡과공사법적만능법률공구。당전교위박절적학술임무,시급지역권수신,우기시요청제“공공지역권”저일사시이비적학술개념조성적지역권허반현상,양지역권회귀기본질。
The concept abuse of easement is a typical example that legal concept is being abused in contemporary academic environment. Essentially, the concept of easement is a legal concept with native nature and certain meanings on legal dogmatics, which should strictly adhere to the purpose of right of private law itself. Nobody should do anything, for example, to incorporate heterogeneous rules with similar characteristic into easement category found in study of comparative law, so as to expand the concept of private law into a versatile legal instrument across public law and private law. Nowadays, it is an urgent academic mission to reduce its content, especially to clear bad effects caused by the specious academic concept "public easement", and to enable easement to regress to its original way.