西北大学学报:哲学社会科学版
西北大學學報:哲學社會科學版
서북대학학보:철학사회과학판
Journal of Northwest University(Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition)
2015年
3期
93~99
,共null页
医疗纠纷 电子病历 证据效力 规范管理
醫療糾紛 電子病歷 證據效力 規範管理
의료규분 전자병력 증거효력 규범관리
medical dispute ; electronics medical records ; evidence validity ; standard management
电子病历作为电子证据在医疗纠纷中的具体化,其效力审查应侧重于原始性和完整性。受电子病历独特属性的限制,加上管理规范性不足以及患者认知度不高等主客观因素制约,其在医疗诉讼中的证据运用情况并不理想。要克服这一弊端,不仅要求法官能够娴熟运用证明责任分配规则,还要充分考虑电子病历的诸多特性。而在电子病历生成、使用环节,还应当通过强化电子病历开发者的维护责任、建立第三方机构保管制度、落实电子病历使用事项告知措施等,规范电子病历日常管理,以确保其精度和证明效力。
電子病歷作為電子證據在醫療糾紛中的具體化,其效力審查應側重于原始性和完整性。受電子病歷獨特屬性的限製,加上管理規範性不足以及患者認知度不高等主客觀因素製約,其在醫療訴訟中的證據運用情況併不理想。要剋服這一弊耑,不僅要求法官能夠嫻熟運用證明責任分配規則,還要充分攷慮電子病歷的諸多特性。而在電子病歷生成、使用環節,還應噹通過彊化電子病歷開髮者的維護責任、建立第三方機構保管製度、落實電子病歷使用事項告知措施等,規範電子病歷日常管理,以確保其精度和證明效力。
전자병력작위전자증거재의료규분중적구체화,기효력심사응측중우원시성화완정성。수전자병력독특속성적한제,가상관리규범성불족이급환자인지도불고등주객관인소제약,기재의료소송중적증거운용정황병불이상。요극복저일폐단,불부요구법관능구한숙운용증명책임분배규칙,환요충분고필전자병력적제다특성。이재전자병력생성、사용배절,환응당통과강화전자병력개발자적유호책임、건립제삼방궤구보관제도、락실전자병력사용사항고지조시등,규범전자병력일상관리,이학보기정도화증명효력。
Electronic medical records as electronic evidence should focus on its effectiveness and integrity of the in medical malpractice in the concrete, the review original. Restricted EHR unique property, coupled with management practices as well as lack of awareness of the patient is not higher subjective and objective factors, as evidenced by the use of medical litigation is not satisfactory. This requires not only a judge can skillfully ap- ply the burden of proof allocation rules, but also to take full account of the many features of electronic medical records. In the electronic medical record generation, the use of links should also be maintained through strengthening responsibility EHR developers to build third party custody system, implement the use of electronic medical records and other items to inform measures, standardized electronic medical records daily manage-ment to ensure its proven efficiency and accuracy.