档案学通讯
檔案學通訊
당안학통신
Archives Science Bulletin
2015年
4期
17~22
,共null页
档案鉴定 档案价值 信息化
檔案鑒定 檔案價值 信息化
당안감정 당안개치 신식화
Archive appraisal; Archival value; Informatization
《错误的价值判定应该被纠正》一文提出“弱化档案鉴定”理念，以纠正错位的价值判定，保证档案的完整性。然而，该文在价值鉴定的“用词”“边界”“主体”等方面认识模糊；论证“弱化鉴定”的前提也不周延，论证视角从鉴定的质向量转换出现偏差；信息技术增强及资金投入等应对也存在缺陷。因而“弱化档案鉴定”的提出，并不是档案鉴定理论的升华，而如今信息社会档案鉴定更必不可少。
《錯誤的價值判定應該被糾正》一文提齣“弱化檔案鑒定”理唸，以糾正錯位的價值判定，保證檔案的完整性。然而，該文在價值鑒定的“用詞”“邊界”“主體”等方麵認識模糊；論證“弱化鑒定”的前提也不週延，論證視角從鑒定的質嚮量轉換齣現偏差；信息技術增彊及資金投入等應對也存在缺陷。因而“弱化檔案鑒定”的提齣，併不是檔案鑒定理論的升華，而如今信息社會檔案鑒定更必不可少。
《착오적개치판정응해피규정》일문제출“약화당안감정”이념，이규정착위적개치판정，보증당안적완정성。연이，해문재개치감정적“용사”“변계”“주체”등방면인식모호；론증“약화감정”적전제야불주연，론증시각종감정적질향량전환출현편차；신식기술증강급자금투입등응대야존재결함。인이“약화당안감정”적제출，병불시당안감정이론적승화，이여금신식사회당안감정경필불가소。
The article, The Wrong Appraisal should be Corrected, puts forward a concept of ＂weaken- ing archive appraisal＂ in order to correct the wrong appraisal and keep archives completely. However, in this paper there are some questions. The first, it has a vague understanding of ＂term＂,＂boundary＂, ＂subject＂ about archive appraisal .The second, its premise is not comprehensive and its argument perspective is devi- atedly exchanged from quality to quantity of archives.The third, the countermeasures of using information technology and capital investment also exist defects.Therefore, the concept of ＂weakening archive appraisal＂ is not a kind of sublimation of the appraisal theory, and the archive appraisal is indispensable in today in- formation society.
