河南工程学院学报(社会科学版)
河南工程學院學報(社會科學版)
하남공정학원학보(사회과학판)
Journal of Hennan Institute of Engineering (Social Science Edition)
2015年
3期
39-44
,共6页
工伤赔偿请求权%第三人侵权%侵权损害赔偿权
工傷賠償請求權%第三人侵權%侵權損害賠償權
공상배상청구권%제삼인침권%침권손해배상권
right to request compensation for work-related injury%third party tort%compensation for tort dam-age
法律规定不一往往引致多样的司法导向,影响社会的安全稳定且有悖于依法治国的法治理念。有关第三人侵权而认定的工伤情形,在司法实践中审判不一。对该问题的探究主要存在替代、选择、补充、兼得四种模式。相比以上四种模式,选择性兼得模式是较为理想的救济模式,契合分配正义与矫正正义,应当在实务中落实。
法律規定不一往往引緻多樣的司法導嚮,影響社會的安全穩定且有悖于依法治國的法治理唸。有關第三人侵權而認定的工傷情形,在司法實踐中審判不一。對該問題的探究主要存在替代、選擇、補充、兼得四種模式。相比以上四種模式,選擇性兼得模式是較為理想的救濟模式,契閤分配正義與矯正正義,應噹在實務中落實。
법률규정불일왕왕인치다양적사법도향,영향사회적안전은정차유패우의법치국적법치이념。유관제삼인침권이인정적공상정형,재사법실천중심판불일。대해문제적탐구주요존재체대、선택、보충、겸득사충모식。상비이상사충모식,선택성겸득모식시교위이상적구제모식,계합분배정의여교정정의,응당재실무중락실。
Inconsistent legal provisions often result in various judicial guidance,influence social security and stability and is contrary to the notion of ruling by law. As to the case of work-related injuries brought by the tort of third party,the trial results do not agree in judicial practice. For the research on the problems there mainly exist four modes:alternative mode,optional mode,supplementary mode,compatible mode. Among those four modes, the optional compatible mode is the more ideal relief mode,which fits the distributive justice and corrective justice, and should be used in practice.