浙江中医药大学学报
浙江中醫藥大學學報
절강중의약대학학보
Journal of Zhejiang Chinese Medical University
2015年
9期
700-703
,共4页
钱小路%尤艳利%舒适%周璇%周爽%朱琴
錢小路%尤豔利%舒適%週璇%週爽%硃琴
전소로%우염리%서괄%주선%주상%주금
荣脑醒神%针灸%卒中后抑郁%卫生经济学评价
榮腦醒神%針灸%卒中後抑鬱%衛生經濟學評價
영뇌성신%침구%졸중후억욱%위생경제학평개
nourishing brain and inducing resuscitation%acupuncture%post-stroke depression%health economics evaluation
[目的]观察荣脑醒神针法对卒中后抑郁的卫生经济学评价。[方法]将符合入组条件的卒中后抑郁患者随机分成2组,针灸组28例与西药组29例。针灸组使用荣脑醒神针法和口服安慰剂,西药组采用盐酸氟西汀20mg口服配合非经非穴假针刺。两组均连续治疗6周,治疗1次/d。3个月后随访,分别统计两组临床疗效、副作用与治疗费用。[结果]在疗效相近(3个月随访时针灸组有效率71.4%,西药组65.5%)且无统计学意义的情况下,荣脑醒神针法治疗卒中后抑郁副作用小,治疗费用与西药组相比,针灸组最低治疗费用较低优于西药组,但总费用较高,成本-效果低于西药组。[结论]荣脑醒神针法治疗卒中后抑郁的最低成本小,但个体费用差异大,综合考虑,该法有一定的临床应用价值,值得临床适应性推广。
[目的]觀察榮腦醒神針法對卒中後抑鬱的衛生經濟學評價。[方法]將符閤入組條件的卒中後抑鬱患者隨機分成2組,針灸組28例與西藥組29例。針灸組使用榮腦醒神針法和口服安慰劑,西藥組採用鹽痠氟西汀20mg口服配閤非經非穴假針刺。兩組均連續治療6週,治療1次/d。3箇月後隨訪,分彆統計兩組臨床療效、副作用與治療費用。[結果]在療效相近(3箇月隨訪時針灸組有效率71.4%,西藥組65.5%)且無統計學意義的情況下,榮腦醒神針法治療卒中後抑鬱副作用小,治療費用與西藥組相比,針灸組最低治療費用較低優于西藥組,但總費用較高,成本-效果低于西藥組。[結論]榮腦醒神針法治療卒中後抑鬱的最低成本小,但箇體費用差異大,綜閤攷慮,該法有一定的臨床應用價值,值得臨床適應性推廣。
[목적]관찰영뇌성신침법대졸중후억욱적위생경제학평개。[방법]장부합입조조건적졸중후억욱환자수궤분성2조,침구조28례여서약조29례。침구조사용영뇌성신침법화구복안위제,서약조채용염산불서정20mg구복배합비경비혈가침자。량조균련속치료6주,치료1차/d。3개월후수방,분별통계량조림상료효、부작용여치료비용。[결과]재료효상근(3개월수방시침구조유효솔71.4%,서약조65.5%)차무통계학의의적정황하,영뇌성신침법치료졸중후억욱부작용소,치료비용여서약조상비,침구조최저치료비용교저우우서약조,단총비용교고,성본-효과저우서약조。[결론]영뇌성신침법치료졸중후억욱적최저성본소,단개체비용차이대,종합고필,해법유일정적림상응용개치,치득림상괄응성추엄。
Objective] To observe nourishing brain and inducing resuscitation method for evaluation of health economics of post-stroke depression. [Methods] Patients who met the criteria were randomly divided into two groups, 28 cases into acupuncture group and 29 cases into western medicine group. Nourishing brain and inducing resuscitation method(acupoints: Shuigou GV26, Neiguan PC6, Zusanli ST36) and oral placebo were used in acupuncture group while fluoxertine hydrochloride and sham acupuncture were used in western medicine group. Patients in both groups were treated daily for 6 six weeks. Follow-up interviews were done in three months and clinical effects, side effects and treatment cost were statistically valued of both groups. [Results] The curative effects of both group was similar(three-month follow-up: acupuncture treatment group effective rate was 71.4%, western medicine group was 65.5%, and the curative effects had no statistical significance. Nourishing brain and inducing resuscitation method treatment of post-stroke depression had less side effects, treatment costs compared with the western medicine group. The lowest cost of acupuncture group was lower than western medicine group. But the total cost of acupuncture group was higher and cost-effectiveness was lower than the western medicine group. [Conclusion] In comprehensive consideration, nourishing brain and inducing resuscitation method treatment of post-stroke depression has a certain clinical application value and is worth clinical promotion.