成都理工大学学报(社会科学版)
成都理工大學學報(社會科學版)
성도리공대학학보(사회과학판)
Journal of Chengdu University of Technology Social Sciences
2015年
6期
89-96
,共8页
受贿案%非法言词证据排除%缺陷%成因%规范化
受賄案%非法言詞證據排除%缺陷%成因%規範化
수회안%비법언사증거배제%결함%성인%규범화
bribery case%illegally obtained verbal evidence%defect%contributing factor%stan-dardization
就证据种类而言,非法言词证据适用绝对排除规则;就排除阶段而言,《刑事诉讼法》对审判阶段排除非法证据的程序规定最为详细。受贿证据以被告人供述、行贿人证言这两种言词证据为主,且辩方更倾向于在审判阶段申请排除非法证据。因此,通过受贿案非法言词证据在审判阶段排除的实证研究,可以分析我国最明确、详细的非法证据排除规则及程序设计的运行实效,并发现实践中的规律与缺陷。现阶段,即使是最为详尽的排除规则,在实际运用中仍缺乏指导性。通过规范化程序设计可以为非法证据排除提供指引并限制裁判机关的自由裁量,矫正缺陷。
就證據種類而言,非法言詞證據適用絕對排除規則;就排除階段而言,《刑事訴訟法》對審判階段排除非法證據的程序規定最為詳細。受賄證據以被告人供述、行賄人證言這兩種言詞證據為主,且辯方更傾嚮于在審判階段申請排除非法證據。因此,通過受賄案非法言詞證據在審判階段排除的實證研究,可以分析我國最明確、詳細的非法證據排除規則及程序設計的運行實效,併髮現實踐中的規律與缺陷。現階段,即使是最為詳儘的排除規則,在實際運用中仍缺乏指導性。通過規範化程序設計可以為非法證據排除提供指引併限製裁判機關的自由裁量,矯正缺陷。
취증거충류이언,비법언사증거괄용절대배제규칙;취배제계단이언,《형사소송법》대심판계단배제비법증거적정서규정최위상세。수회증거이피고인공술、행회인증언저량충언사증거위주,차변방경경향우재심판계단신청배제비법증거。인차,통과수회안비법언사증거재심판계단배제적실증연구,가이분석아국최명학、상세적비법증거배제규칙급정서설계적운행실효,병발현실천중적규률여결함。현계단,즉사시최위상진적배제규칙,재실제운용중잉결핍지도성。통과규범화정서설계가이위비법증거배제제공지인병한제재판궤관적자유재량,교정결함。
For the kinds of evidence,illegally obtained verbal evidence should be absolutely expelled.For stages,the exclusion procedure in trail stage is legislated most detailed in Criminal Proceduer Law .The confession and exculpation of the defendant and testimony of the briber are the primary evidences in bribery cases.What is more,the defence tend to apply for exclusion procedure at the trial stages.So making an empirical study on the exclusinary rules of illegally obtained verbal evidence in bribery cases at trial stage ,we can analyze the implement of the most obvious exclusion rules in our country and find out the defects in them.At the present stage,the most clear exclusion rules also lack guiding effects.In order to correct the defect,standardized procedure should be legislated to guide and limite the discretion of judging organs.