重庆理工大学学报(社会科学版)
重慶理工大學學報(社會科學版)
중경리공대학학보(사회과학판)
Journal of Chongqing Institute of Technology
2015年
10期
101-105,121
,共6页
明显不当%程序性违法%行政强制%行政惯例
明顯不噹%程序性違法%行政彊製%行政慣例
명현불당%정서성위법%행정강제%행정관례
obvious inappropriateness%procedural illegal%administrative coercion%administrative practice
变更判决的适用范围不应当仅限于行政裁量权领域,而应当扩大到程序性违法领域。变更判决适用的行为种类不应仅限于行政处罚与有关款额的确定确有错误时,而应当扩展到新《行政诉讼法》明确规定的行政附带民事诉讼领域。从理论上来看,行政强制领域也应当被纳入变更判决的适用范围之内。“明显不当”从实质意义上来说是对“违法”的侧面反映,“明显不当”的判断标准可以从是否违反行政惯例,是否背离立法目的与立法精神层面来考察。
變更判決的適用範圍不應噹僅限于行政裁量權領域,而應噹擴大到程序性違法領域。變更判決適用的行為種類不應僅限于行政處罰與有關款額的確定確有錯誤時,而應噹擴展到新《行政訴訟法》明確規定的行政附帶民事訴訟領域。從理論上來看,行政彊製領域也應噹被納入變更判決的適用範圍之內。“明顯不噹”從實質意義上來說是對“違法”的側麵反映,“明顯不噹”的判斷標準可以從是否違反行政慣例,是否揹離立法目的與立法精神層麵來攷察。
변경판결적괄용범위불응당부한우행정재량권영역,이응당확대도정서성위법영역。변경판결괄용적행위충류불응부한우행정처벌여유관관액적학정학유착오시,이응당확전도신《행정소송법》명학규정적행정부대민사소송영역。종이론상래간,행정강제영역야응당피납입변경판결적괄용범위지내。“명현불당”종실질의의상래설시대“위법”적측면반영,“명현불당”적판단표준가이종시부위반행정관례,시부배리입법목적여입법정신층면래고찰。
The applicable scope of the change of decision should not be limited to the scope of admin-istrative discretion,but shall be extended to the procedural illegal domain.Change of decision for the types of action should not be confined to administrative penalties and the error determination of pay-ments,but shall be extended to the field of administrative litigation incidental civil action in adminis-trative procedure law.In theory,administrative coercion areas should also be included in the scope of the change of decision.From the real significance,“obvious inappropriateness”is reflected to the“illegal”.The judgment standards of “obvious inappropriateness”can be that whether it is infringing administrative practice and departing from the legislative purpose and legislative spirit seriously or not.