南华大学学报(社会科学版)
南華大學學報(社會科學版)
남화대학학보(사회과학판)
Journal of University of South China (Social Science Edition)
2015年
5期
77-82
,共6页
刑事二审%新证据%认定标准%采信
刑事二審%新證據%認定標準%採信
형사이심%신증거%인정표준%채신
criminal appeal procedure%new evidence%criterion%admissibility
刑事二审中新证据的采信对于查明案件事实有重大意义,但刑事诉讼法只是原则性的规定了新证据,对其构成要件及采信标准则需要参照相关司法解释及部门法进一步明确。理论上讲,我国对新证据采取的是随时提出主义,反映了对刑事实质正义的绝对追求。具体到新证据的认定标准上,需要考察时间、原因和种类三个要件。在此基础上,结合证据的可采性原理,可以分别对检察院、辩护人及法院提出的新证据进行科学的采信。
刑事二審中新證據的採信對于查明案件事實有重大意義,但刑事訴訟法隻是原則性的規定瞭新證據,對其構成要件及採信標準則需要參照相關司法解釋及部門法進一步明確。理論上講,我國對新證據採取的是隨時提齣主義,反映瞭對刑事實質正義的絕對追求。具體到新證據的認定標準上,需要攷察時間、原因和種類三箇要件。在此基礎上,結閤證據的可採性原理,可以分彆對檢察院、辯護人及法院提齣的新證據進行科學的採信。
형사이심중신증거적채신대우사명안건사실유중대의의,단형사소송법지시원칙성적규정료신증거,대기구성요건급채신표준칙수요삼조상관사법해석급부문법진일보명학。이론상강,아국대신증거채취적시수시제출주의,반영료대형사실질정의적절대추구。구체도신증거적인정표준상,수요고찰시간、원인화충류삼개요건。재차기출상,결합증거적가채성원리,가이분별대검찰원、변호인급법원제출적신증거진행과학적채신。
Although new evidence plays a very importance role in the criminal appeal procedure, it is so obscure in criminal pro-cedure law that it needs further interpretation. Theoretically, new evidence can be submitted to court at any time. However, the admis-sibility of it is limited by time, reason and category on which we can make the determination from the prosecutor, attorney and judge specifically.