中华眼视光学与视觉科学杂志
中華眼視光學與視覺科學雜誌
중화안시광학여시각과학잡지
Chinese Journal of Optometry Ophthalmology and Visual Science
2015年
10期
604-608
,共5页
吴凡%黄锦海%鲁伟聪%包芳军%黎远光%王勤美
吳凡%黃錦海%魯偉聰%包芳軍%黎遠光%王勤美
오범%황금해%로위총%포방군%려원광%왕근미
体层摄影术,光学相干%超声检查,A型%中央角膜厚度%可重复性,结果%一致性
體層攝影術,光學相榦%超聲檢查,A型%中央角膜厚度%可重複性,結果%一緻性
체층섭영술,광학상간%초성검사,A형%중앙각막후도%가중복성,결과%일치성
Tomography,optical coherence%Ultrasonography,A%Central corneal thickness%Reproducibility of result%Agreement
目的:评估CASIA SS-1000新型扫频OCT (SS-1000 OCT)测量正常人中央角膜厚度(CCT)的重复性,并与A型超声测厚仪结果进行比较,评估2种仪器的一致性。方法前瞻性研究。收集正常受检者62名,均由同一熟练操作者对受检者右眼进行测量,先采用非接触SS-1000 OCT,再使用A超重复测量角膜厚度。组内标准系数(ICC)、Bland-Altman及重复测量方差分析用于评估SS-1000 OCT测量 CCT 的重复性;配对 t 检验及 Bland-Altman 用于评估 SS-1000 OCT 与 A 超的一致性。结果SS-1000 OCT重复3次测量CCT的ICC为0.999,第1次与第2欠、第1次与第3次及第2次与第3次的95%一致性区间分别为-2.4~1.8μm、-2.8~2.1μm、-2.8~2.7μm,重复测量方差分析进行两两比较显示差异无统计学意义。 SS-1000 OCT及A超测量CCT的均值分别为(534.38±24.52)μm和(538.40±25.36)μm,二者95%一致性区间为-12.6~4.5μm。结论 SS-1000 OCT测量CCT具有很好的重复性,与A型超声测厚仪具有高度的一致性,在临床工作中,可以考虑相互替代。
目的:評估CASIA SS-1000新型掃頻OCT (SS-1000 OCT)測量正常人中央角膜厚度(CCT)的重複性,併與A型超聲測厚儀結果進行比較,評估2種儀器的一緻性。方法前瞻性研究。收集正常受檢者62名,均由同一熟練操作者對受檢者右眼進行測量,先採用非接觸SS-1000 OCT,再使用A超重複測量角膜厚度。組內標準繫數(ICC)、Bland-Altman及重複測量方差分析用于評估SS-1000 OCT測量 CCT 的重複性;配對 t 檢驗及 Bland-Altman 用于評估 SS-1000 OCT 與 A 超的一緻性。結果SS-1000 OCT重複3次測量CCT的ICC為0.999,第1次與第2欠、第1次與第3次及第2次與第3次的95%一緻性區間分彆為-2.4~1.8μm、-2.8~2.1μm、-2.8~2.7μm,重複測量方差分析進行兩兩比較顯示差異無統計學意義。 SS-1000 OCT及A超測量CCT的均值分彆為(534.38±24.52)μm和(538.40±25.36)μm,二者95%一緻性區間為-12.6~4.5μm。結論 SS-1000 OCT測量CCT具有很好的重複性,與A型超聲測厚儀具有高度的一緻性,在臨床工作中,可以攷慮相互替代。
목적:평고CASIA SS-1000신형소빈OCT (SS-1000 OCT)측량정상인중앙각막후도(CCT)적중복성,병여A형초성측후의결과진행비교,평고2충의기적일치성。방법전첨성연구。수집정상수검자62명,균유동일숙련조작자대수검자우안진행측량,선채용비접촉SS-1000 OCT,재사용A초중복측량각막후도。조내표준계수(ICC)、Bland-Altman급중복측량방차분석용우평고SS-1000 OCT측량 CCT 적중복성;배대 t 검험급 Bland-Altman 용우평고 SS-1000 OCT 여 A 초적일치성。결과SS-1000 OCT중복3차측량CCT적ICC위0.999,제1차여제2흠、제1차여제3차급제2차여제3차적95%일치성구간분별위-2.4~1.8μm、-2.8~2.1μm、-2.8~2.7μm,중복측량방차분석진행량량비교현시차이무통계학의의。 SS-1000 OCT급A초측량CCT적균치분별위(534.38±24.52)μm화(538.40±25.36)μm,이자95%일치성구간위-12.6~4.5μm。결론 SS-1000 OCT측량CCT구유흔호적중복성,여A형초성측후의구유고도적일치성,재림상공작중,가이고필상호체대。
Objective To assess the repeatability of central corneal thickness (CCT) measurements in healthy eyes by comparing measurements obtained with an SS-1000 swept-source optical coherence tomography (SS-1000 OCT) or by ultrasound pachymetry (USP); to evaluate the agreement between these two devices. Methods In this prospective study, CCT was recorded after consecutive measurements with SS-1000 OCT and then with USP by a single skilled operator in 62 right eyes of healthy subjects. Intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), Bland-Altman plots and repeated-measures analysis of variance (ANOVA) were used to evaluate the repeatability of SS-1000 OCT. Paired t-tests and Bland-Altman plots were used to evaluate the agreement between the two devices. Results The ICC of the SS-1000 OCT measurements was 0.999. Bland-Altman plots showed excellent agreement between any two of the three measurements (95% limits of agreement were -2.4 to 1.8 μm, -2.8 to 2.1 μm, and -2.8 to 2.7 μm). There was no statistical significance found with repeated-measures ANOVA. The mean values of CCT obtained from the SS-1000 OCT and USP were 534.38 ±24.52 μm and 538.40 ±25.36 μm, respectively. 95% limits of agreement were -12.6 to 4.5 μm for these two devices. Conclusion The SS-1000 OCT shows excellent repeatability of CCT measurements in healthy eyes. High agreement between CCT measurements suggests that SS-1000 OCT and USP can be used interchangeably in normal subjects.